5 Ways Justice League Is His Masterpiece (& 5 Why It’s Watchmen)
As for his supporters, Justice League by Zack Snyder (aka The Snyder Cut) was everything they could have hoped for and more. The director’s raw vision of the Justice League has exceeded expectations, with many considering it his best film to date.
That said, Justice LeagueThe re-examination of some recalled Guardians, Snyder’s equally divisive superhero film that was given new life after its release. The question is no longer whether every movie is good, but what Snyder’s comic book masterpiece is – and why.
ten JUSTICE LEAGUE: Snyder Cut’s story predates the movie
Of all his movies, nothing will define Snyder in the way Justice League– especially the Snyder Cut – will be. When word got out that Snyder’s superhero movie was heavily compromised and reworked after its release, its completeness became something of a myth. Four years later, the Snyder Cut was finally over, but not without its controversy.
Guardians, on the other hand, is a true cult classic. Although divisive in its opening week, it has since developed a dedicated fan base and is now generally considered an underrated superhero gem. Guardians is not the first nor the last film to be confirmed by time, while Justice LeagueThe legacy of history is something for history books.
9 WATCHMEN: its theatrical cut can be autonomous
Frankly, the Snyder Cut is leagues above its theatrical version. Or Justice League was a randomly edited mess with an inconsistent tone, the Snyder Cut was a flawed but admirably ambitious superhero epic. Newcomers should start with the Snyder Cut and only watch the theatrical version for comparison or curiosity purposes.
On the other hand, GuardiansThe theatrical cut works perfectly as is. The film also has a version of almost 3 hours in The ultimate fit, but its excised material only improves what there is instead of fixing it. Restored content includes deleted scenes like Hollis Mason’s death and the comic book anime adaptation in the universe Tales of the Black Freighter.
8 JUSTICE LEAGUE: It’s more epic in scope
Justice League was a victim of its own ambition, making it arguably the most admirable and interesting film. The DCEU First Team was the start of a trilogy detailing the invasion of Darkseid, with elements of Breaking point added for good measure. Sadly, the next two chapters are unlikely to ever be made after Snyder’s fallout with Warner Bros.
Like his comic book, Guardians closes with an open ending but it’s still a standalone job. Even though the comics had follow-ups Before Watchmen, End of the world clock, and the HBO show, the movie is its own thing that aspires to nothing but do justice to the source material. Although he has accomplished this, he leaves little to the imagination the way Justice League Is.
7 WATCHMEN: It’s a perfect visual recreation of the comics
Next to Robert Rodriguez Sin city, Snyder’s Guardians is the closest a comic could ever come to life. The film perfectly recreates the garishly colored world of the comics and updates the heroes’ costumes to match the superhero trends of the 2000s, both of which help make the comic book feel dark and oppressive.
Although run by the same person, Justice League is inferior to Guardians in terms of visuals. The color scheme is dull, the action gets excessive, and the visuals have swapped the wild worlds of DC Comics for mundane realism. Even with the occasional spaceship, Justice League confused “boring” for “realistic”. And even so, its realistic backgrounds lack courage and style. Guardians.
6 JUSTICE LEAGUE: This Is The Best Ensemble Superhero Movie
Due to time constraints, Guardians had to shorten certain character backgrounds and eliminate entire world-building side stories altogether. For example, the Minutemen and Malcolm Long barely get any screen time, and Bernie is exclusive to The ultimate fit. The arcs of the central Watchmen are practically summed up, like a shortened version of Doctor Manhattan’s flashback.
Since Justice League focuses on seven heroes, they have more time to develop. Better yet, The Snyder Cut is divided into chapters, with some detailing the entire origins (i.e. Cyborg and The Flash) while others building the camaraderie (i.e. Batman and Wonder Woman) for others. Thanks to its smaller distribution, Justice League shows his characters better than Guardians could.
5 WATCHMEN: Rorschach stole the show
Guardians The actors did a great job bringing their respective characters to life, but all are pale compared to Jackie Earle Haley as Rorschach. At the time, Haley’s portrayal of the paranoid vigilante was considered an incredible find, and he has since grown into one of the most trusted actors in the business.
Haley brought humanity to an otherwise reprehensible misanthropist, making him likable but someone not to aspire to be. It’s not uncommon to hear people recommend Guardians solely on the presence of Rorschach, and that’s because he’s basically the main event. To this day, Haley’s Rorschach remains one of the best superhero movie performances ever.
4 JUSTICE LEAGUE: He has the most iconic cast
Snyder’s films can be divisive, but one thing he’s always praised for is his strong casting skills. Nowhere is this clearer than in Justice League, which has arguably one of the strongest casts he has assembled to date. The line-up includes veteran actors and relative newcomers, all of whom excel in their designated roles.
Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman castings are still the DCEU’s most popular castings, while also putting untested Jason Momoa and Ray Fisher in Aquaman and Cyborg, respectively. Seeing everyone playing each other perfectly in the Snyder Cut is the kind of entertainment that can’t be easily duplicated.
3 WATCHMEN: It’s the best adaptation
Guardians stands out for its loyalty to comics. With few exceptions, the film is an individual recreation of its source material. Alan Moore’s dialogue is recited verbatim, and the visuals are the art of Dave Gibbons in live-action. In fact, one of the GuardiansThe biggest flaws of too much faithful, hence the amount of excised material.
Justice League, meanwhile, is not based on a specific arc or scenario. Instead, it condenses different DC comics and concepts into what can best be described as a bolder tale of The Avengers. The two share the same plot of forming a team of superheroes to stop an alien invasion, but Justice League falls short of its MCU counterpart.
2 JUSTICE LEAGUE: He rebuilt the DCEU
Snyder’s DC Universe had polarized from the start. Steel man recast Superman as a dreaded divine alien, while Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice pit a reluctant Superman against a murderous Batman. However, Snyder’s brooding story decisions and creative freedoms only made sense in Justice League.
In the Snyder Cut, previously disillusioned and jaded heroes unite under Superman’s example to defend the world. Essentially, Justice League defeats the deconstructing superhero archetype dark and edgy with good old-fashioned heroism. Yes Justice League were left to Snyder’s devices, the DCEU wouldn’t be as heavy and confusing as it currently is.
1 WATCHMEN: He deconstructed superheroes before deconstruction craze
Right now, superhero deconstructions are more popular than ever. The cynical and the bloody The boys and Invincible are the most popular superhero shows right now, and non-comedy movies like Brightburn and Project power won’t be the last edgy superhero movies. In these respects, Guardians was ahead of its time.
contrary to The black Knight trilogy which was more of a character study and a thriller anchored with Batman, Guardians deconstruct superheroes from within, playing by the rules of the genre. Like his comic book, Guardians interviewed and tested costumed crime fighters and a literal real-world superpower, circa 1986. It is only now, in hindsight, that GuardiansDeconstructions are fully appreciated.
NEXT: Watchmen: 10 More Comic Book Movies That Should Make Follow Up TV Shows
10 MCU heroes Venom could defeat
About the Author